Cook'd and Bomb'd Mafia: Blodwyn's Island Day 2 - Charlie's War

[Paul Calf]

Sorry to be unhelpful but I've literally not got the foggiest at this stage. Gonna wait till we uncover a bit more info.

No. If anything, I'm even less sure than I was yesterday.

I'm sorry my actions yesterday led us to this. Perhaps as cellar said there is something to be learned from the vote. Given the invaders know it was an all town argument.

One death is interesting, presuming the doc protected either the night kill or the vig's target. One might just not have done anything though.

Going to keep quiet today I think, yesterday was a disaster and you would better be served by me not causing pointless diversions.

How do they know that? How do we know that?

[Jim Bob]

Anyway, could everyone please report in and say what they've been up to?  There are some very bewildered-looking cows out there.

Pfft.  You say bewildered, I say impressed.

[Cerys]

Duly noted.

[BlodwynPig]

Can people stop saying "Jim" when they're not referring to me, please?  It's very confusing and it could result in misinformed voting.  Refer to Delete as Bergerac, if you must abide by that name.  Ta.

I'm afraid not. For the purposes of the game you have been given an identity, please use it.

[drummersaredeaf]

Come on, let's get this moving then. Otherwise I'll spin a random number thing and just vote to lynch whoever it lands on.

[drummersaredeaf]

In fact, no - fuck it.

I'll name the person I thought was acting suspiciously - Kryton.

[gib]

No. If anything, I'm even less sure than I was yesterday.

How do they know that? How do we know that?

This surely has to be TIWS slipping up

vote TIWS

[Delete Delete Delete]

Good choice. What makes him suspicious to you? 

Vote Kryton

[drummersaredeaf]

OK VOTE TIWS

Outline it for me, what's the slip up they've made here?

[gib]

I'm going to put my effort into rereading day one, je serai de retour plus tard

[Buelligan]

I'm sorry my actions yesterday led us to this. Perhaps as cellar said there is something to be learned from the vote. Given the invaders know it was an all town argument.

One death is interesting, presuming the doc protected either the night kill or the vig's target. One might just not have done anything though.

Going to keep quiet today I think, yesterday was a disaster and you would better be served by me not causing pointless diversions.

How do they know that? How do we know that?

I agree, we don't know that. 

On your point TIWS, IMO, being quiet helps no one.  Being honest is the way.  If you have suspicions, say so and say why, clearly and honestly.  Don't exaggerate.  If you just think something's suspicious but you don't know why say that too.  Make it clear what you think and why you think it.

[Delete Delete Delete]

VOTE TIWS

[drummersaredeaf]

Re: Kryton - there were hints of sailing too close to the wind. Playing to the other forum potentially.

Madhair was also acting in a kind of similar way though, and that would have been an incorrect call.

[gib]

OK VOTE TIWS

Outline it for me, what's the slip up they've made here?

Paul has already outlined it.

[Cerys]

I'm not convinced that it was a slip-up by an invader, but what the hell.  Vote TIWS.

[Paul Calf]

This surely has to be TIWS slipping up

vote TIWS

They also said they were going to be quiet today.  Vote player TIWS

[Buelligan]

Vote TIWS but underline that we're not done for the day, we must keep looking at everyone, there are four of them to find.

[drummersaredeaf]

Paul has already outlined it.

OK, the invaders know that yesterday was an all-town argument, and so it appears likely that he is an invader who was in the midst of it who slipped up by disclosing that he knows it was all town?

[Delete Delete Delete]

Re: Kryton - there were hints of sailing too close to the wind. Playing to the other forum potentially.

Madhair was also acting in a kind of similar way though, and that would have been an incorrect call.

Just going through some Kryton posts.

Why is everyone self voting. You should be kicking and screaming your innocence/fake innocence.
That's what I'd hypothetically be doing.

Why hypothetically doing, why not actually doing?

Alright what's your strategy. Gimme your game plan.

Digging for Townie Strats?

We're perfectly within our rights to abstain. Aren't we?

Encouraging people not to vote?

Just a couple of things, id' like to ponder for a bit.

[This isnt witty sorry]

Sorry I can see how that looks but I only meant that I know myself to be town, cellar to be town and I believe buelligan to be town as well.

[drummersaredeaf]

Just going through some Kryton posts.

Why hypothetically doing, why not actually doing?


Digging for Townie Strats?

Encouraging people not to vote?

Just a couple of things, id' like to ponder for a bit.

I'm not sure. Quite a few of them kind of add up for Day 1. Everyone would certainly protest innocence, and the self-voting thing is definitely not clever. But you are right that perhaps the 'hypothetical' point might be a subconscious misstep. It could also mean hypothetically if you were under the microscope too though - which he wasn't.

It was more the tone of posting, and the murder hotel that was drawing my eye.

[Paul Calf]

I thought 'hypothetical' was reference to the fact that he wasn't under attack so the situation he was discussing didn't apply?

[Delete Delete Delete]

Perhaps Kryton may be a good target for the Cop to investigate.

[kittens]

i got no idea what's going on. je suis gotta lotta catchin up to do

[Ferris]

I understand it is not possible to have a post mortem for Madhair, therefore, I suggest that it's not useful to assume he was killed by the Invaders.  I accept his sad death but draw no definitive conclusion from it.  I keep an open mind on this.

He was killed because his erratic play style looked like a weird bluff, and I don't think we questioned it so the wolves assumed we were covering for him (and not realizing that it looked just as odd to us as it did to them).

Vote player Cerys, convinced you and buellers are bad news

[Ferris]

(Buelligan please don't think I'm targeting you for no reason! God this game makes me feel guilty)

[Kryton]

Sorry I arrived late.

Terrible tragedy on our shores.
Rather startled to see people voting for myself.

I have my own suspicions. In fact I had my own strategies yesterday which seem to have largely been ignored by the rest of the town.

[BlodwynPig]

He was killed because his erratic play style looked like a weird bluff, and I don't think we questioned it so the wolves assumed we were covering for him (and not realizing that it looked just as odd to us as it did to them).

Vote player Cerys, convinced you and buellers are bad news

Wolves? On Jersey? You've had fair warning, but I will let this pass as you're obviously sleep deprived

[Cerys]

Vote player Cerys, convinced you and buellers are bad news

What reason do you have for targeting me?  I'm innocent and curious.

[Kryton]

Why hypothetically doing, why not actually doing?

At that point I wasn't accused.

Digging for Townie Strats?

Some strats are better than none. Don't forget yesterday you all took JimBob at his word and got an innocent hanged.

Encouraging people not to vote?

Nope, explaining that you don't have to vote. It wasn't encouraging, more of a reminder.

Just a couple of things, id' like to ponder for a bit.

Ponder away.


Don't forget that the last person to accuse me was Buelligan who now has innocent townie blood on her hands. At least I was willing to try and get the voting on some kind of parity and leave it to the 50/50 fates.