Taking it too far?

[Bigfella]

There will always be debate about what kind of material should be off limits for whatever reason.  What about physical acts on stage?  What is unacceptable?  Personally, I suppose I could live with somebody spitting or breaking wind on stage.  I draw the line at having a crap or getting your dick out, that's a bit much.

[Swoz_MK]

Dirty Sanchez impressed me with a bit of cannibalism, that was good.

[Utter Shit]

I just don't see why they need to be so rude.

[Johnny Foreigner]

Performing naked is all-right as a kind of statement, I suppose, although it's a bit niche.

To me, vulgarity for the sake of vulgarity is more offensive than a human body. Let's say I am glad Chubby Arse isn't real.

[JaDanketies]

I think I'd be okay with someone showing us their prolapse on stage.

[wrec]

I draw the line at having a crap or getting your dick out, that's a bit much.

This suggests the idea of GG Allin style antics done not for confrontational, shock impact but purely for comedic value

[Noodle Lizard]

Jerry Sadowitz has pulled his dick out more or less every time I've seen him (although one time it was fake). I can't recall any context for it, really, but it fit in with the general ambience of his performance, and willies are inherently quite funny of course.

I couldn't count the amount of musicians who do stuff like that as part of a live performance, though, so I'm not sure it's fair to suggest comedy should be any more restricted. I think unless it comes to physical confrontations with the audience, it's fair enough.

[Bigfella]

Jerry Sadowitz has pulled his dick out more or less every time I've seen him (although one time it was fake). I can't recall any context for it, really, but it fit in with the general ambience of his performance, and willies are inherently quite funny of course.

I couldn't count the amount of musicians who do stuff like that as part of a live performance, though, so I'm not sure it's fair to suggest comedy should be any more restricted. I think unless it comes to physical confrontations with the audience, it's fair enough.

I'm not trying to lay down the law, there would be a time and a place for it. Puppetry of the Penis - okay, clue's in the name so you know what you're getting.  C.K. Lewis - no thanks, we know he'd enjoy it too much.

[Virgo76]

There was indeed a time and a place for that kind of thing. Unfortunately it was in France in about 1397 AD.